Coinkite CEO says Coldcard flaw hit 0.17% of users as Galaxy tallies $116M in stolen Bitcoin
Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak says a firmware flaw in Coldcard hardware wallets affected about 0.17% of the company's users. That sounds small until you see the damage report.Galaxy Research estimates the flaw led to the theft of approximately 1,830 BTC, worth an estimated $116 million at the time. For a product whose entire pitch is keeping your Bitcoin away from hackers, that is an awkward number to explain.According to the research findings, the trouble traces back to a firmware update shipped in March 2021, versions 4.0.0 and 4.0.1. Under certain conditions, affected devices fell back on a weak software pseudorandom number generator when creating seeds.The result was seeds with significantly reduced entropy, which is the technical term for unpredictability. Lower entropy shrinks the pool of possible combinations, and a small enough pool can be searched.That is what made the attack possible. Attackers could reconstruct affected seed phrases offline, without touching the device or tricking the owner into anything.Galaxy Research tracked the exploitation, which began on July 30, 2026. The theft ran through August 4, 2026, hitting around 9,200 addresses in total.Coinkite began releasing emergency firmware patches on July 31, 2026, one day after the draining started.There is also a catch with the fix. A patch can stop a device from generating weak seeds going forward, but it cannot retroactively strengthen a seed that was already created badly.Users with compromised seeds need to generate new ones and move their funds to the fresh wallets. Updating the firmware alone leaves the old, guessable seed exactly where it was.Novak's 0.17% estimate is drawn from loss reports and internal production data, according to the research findings. It is an estimate, not a precise headcount.Coinkite's own design philosophy complicates the math. The company builds its products around privacy, which means it does not track who owns what or how much sits in each wallet.So the public picture rests on two different lenses. Coinkite offers a share of users, while Galaxy offers a blockchain-level tally of coins and addresses.The legal fallout arrived in September. A class-action lawsuit was filed in Ontario on September 11, 2026, against Coinkite and its senior executives.The suit alleges the company failed to adequately warn users, despite internal notifications about the issue reportedly arriving as early as May 2025. That would mean more than a year passed between the alleged early warnings and the start of the theft.Those are allegations, and they have not been tested in court. Still, the gap between May 2025 and July 2026 is likely to be the center of gravity for the case.The question will be what Coinkite knew, when it knew it, and whether it told customers enough.The research findings suggest the incident could dampen confidence in hardware wallets, particularly among self-custody advocates. The findings also point to potential regulatory interest in how wallet makers disclose vulnerabilities and protect user funds.For Coinkite, the immediate test is execution. Every affected user who has not yet generated a new seed and moved their coins remains exposed, regardless of which firmware version they are running.The Ontario case is the next thing to watch. Its handling of the alleged May 2025 warnings could shape how hardware wallet companies approach disclosure for years.A 0.17% hit rate reads as reassuring in a press statement, while $116 million in stolen Bitcoin reads very differently to the people who held it.