Democratic Sweep Likely Keeps Crypto in Legislative Paralysis — Analysis

Dow Jones Newswires

Democratic Sweep Likely Keeps Crypto in Legislative Paralysis — Analysis

By Dean SealA Republican Congress and White House failed to pass comprehensive legislation around cryptocurrency in the past two years. The Democrats' resounding midterm victory probably means more years of Congressional paralysis for the industry, experts said.Despite pouring massive sums of money into the elections to push for favorable change, the crypto industry has little to show for it after Tuesday night.Crypto political action committees, or PACs, spent heavily on the Ohio Senate race to defeat Sherrod Brown, a Democrat and crypto critic, only for Brown to prevail. He now rejoins a Senate with a Democratic majority that's poised to give financial-regulation hawk Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D., Mass.) the helm of the Senate Banking Committee in January.A Democrat-led Senate likely won't have much interest in advancing the crypto-friendly Clarity Act that stalled out in September from a lack of support among Democrats and four Republicans.The incoming Congress is expected to instead focus its efforts on probing President Trump's entanglements with the crypto industry, experts said. Trump took home more than $1 billion from crypto-related business in 2025, the first year of his second term."We believe the resulting political environment may make it impossible to advance a version of Clarity that the crypto sector could back," TD Cowen analyst Jaret Seiberg said in a research note.Kalshi markets currently place the odds of the Clarity Act becoming law by the end of 2026 at 2.5%, and give it a 21% chance of getting enacted before 2028.New PrioritiesFor the Clarity Act to get revived, or for some new piece of crypto legislation to find legs, lawmakers will probably want to see more emphasis on consumer protections, industry observers said. They'll likely also seek language addressing conflicts of interest and creating a division of authority between regulators, Moon Pursuit Capital's Utkarsh Ahuja said.Senate Republicans drafted the Clarity Act to create a federal framework for regulating digital assets and crypto markets, including asset classifications and registration qualifications for market intermediaries.The bill fell short in a September procedural vote after Senate Democrats voiced concerns about a lack of safeguards against political self-dealing in the crypto industry. Ahead of the vote, Sen. Warren said the Clarity Act wouldn't prevent Trump from continuing to profit from his own crypto ventures while using his political power to boost the industry.The path to making a deal now is more complicated, Ahuja said, leaving regulators to continue developing rules under their existing authority. "Legislative progress and regulatory activity may therefore move at different speeds," he said.Even if Democratic lawmakers do ultimately make crypto a priority, the industry will still need to spend time building relationships with Congress's new members, who may be less acquainted with digital assets, according to Jessica Martinez, the U.S. policy director at Fireblocks."There's also a real opportunity to reset the conversation around crypto in Washington and make progress on issues that matter to the industry," Martinez said.Regulators Fill the VoidIn the meantime, regulators that have adopted the Trump administration's pro-crypto agenda will continue to serve as the industry's immediate rulemakers.Following the Clarity Act's collapse, the Securities and Exchange Commission moved to allow tokenized stock trading while the Commodity Futures Trading Commission advanced regulations for retail crypto commodity markets.The agencies will want to keep pushing their crypto-friendly policies forward, albeit at a potentially slower pace, according to Martin Lee at crypto market maker DWF Labs. If they can, the industry is due for further adoption and progress, though any fracturing within the government could wind up making retail investors more skeptical of crypto overall, he said.Above all, any agency rulemakings on crypto could prove temporary, as they can be reversed by future administrations or superseded by any statute that Congress ultimately agrees on.That leaves the industry with two years in which U.S. crypto policy will be steered by the SEC's interpretive releases and the incoming Congress's expected hearings on Trump's crypto dealings, said Wojciech Kaszycki, a strategy adviser of the Polish digital-asset company BTCS S.A. "The industry should get used to subpoenas replacing bills," he said.A workable bipartisan framework for crypto could still happen down the road, given that the U.S. has an incentive to innovate, experts said. Otherwise, it could see the industry flee to nations that are issuing licenses instead of holding hearings, including Abu Dhabi, Dubai and Hong Kong, according to Kaszycki."That is where the next two years of capital and talent will go," Kaszycki said.Write to Dean Seal at [email protected]