German judge floats dropping Movie2k case in exchange for 40,000 BTC

Crypto Briefing

German judge floats dropping Movie2k case in exchange for 40,000 BTC

A German judge has proposed ending one of the country's biggest crypto-linked criminal cases with a payment rather than a verdict. The price is 40,000 Bitcoin, worth about $2.6 billion.The defendant is Josef F., the alleged operator of the long-defunct illegal streaming site Movie2k.to. If he accepts, the criminal proceedings against him could be dismissed. He would also reportedly still hold around 16,000 BTC afterward, which makes this an unusual kind of settlement.The proposal comes from Karsten Nickel, the presiding judge at the Leipzig Regional Court. Under his suggestion, Josef F. would transfer 40,000 BTC to authorities. That stake is valued at roughly €2.5–2.6 billion.The Bitcoin is only part of the package. The deal also calls for a €38 million compensation payment to potential victims, such as rights holders whose content may have been streamed without permission.There is a third condition as well. Josef F. would have to give up any claims to proceeds from earlier sales of his assets. Those sales brought in about €2.64 billion.Josef F. is estimated to control about 56,000 BTC in total. Hand over 40,000 and he would still have roughly 16,000 left, which is estimated to be worth more than $1 billion at current prices.Movie2k.to shut down in 2013. Josef F. was arrested in 2023. In January 2024, he transferred nearly 50,000 BTC to German authorities to avoid pre-trial detention.Authorities then sold those coins during the summer of 2024. The sales generated around €2.64 billion. That is the same pool of proceeds he would have to renounce any claim to under the new proposal.His trial began in early 2026. It covers 146 counts of commercial money laundering and related offenses.The numbers create an awkward comparison. Authorities sold nearly 50,000 BTC for about €2.64 billion in 2024. Now 40,000 BTC is valued at roughly €2.5–2.6 billion. Fewer coins are worth nearly as much as the earlier, larger batch.For the German state, the logic is easy to follow. A long money laundering trial with 146 counts eats court time and carries uncertainty. A settlement locks in a large transfer of value and compensation for victims without the risk of an acquittal or a drawn-out appeal.For now, the proposal is just that: a proposal. Josef F. has to decide whether surrendering 40,000 BTC, paying €38 million to potential victims and abandoning claims to about €2.64 billion in earlier sale proceeds is worth ending the case. Keeping roughly 16,000 BTC on the other side of that decision is not the worst consolation prize a defendant has ever been offered.